RubinBrown Gaming Stats 2011
Welcome to the 2011 edition of RubinBrown’s Gaming Statistics publication, which provides a comprehensive review of the United States gaming industry.
Commercial & Tribal Gaming Stats A Publication of RubinBrown LLP 2011
Welcome Letter
Contents 1 Welcome Letter
2 Executive Summary 3 National Comparison 4 State Gaming Tax Revenues 5 Regional Comparison 13 Colorado Gaming Statistics 17 Illinois Gaming Statistics 21 Indiana Gaming Statistics 25 Iowa Gaming Statistics 29 Missouri Gaming Statistics 33 National Indian Gaming Analysis 35 Regional Indian Gaming Analysis 37 Arizona Indian Gaming Analysis 39 Colorado Indian Gaming Analysis 40 Kansas Indian Gaming Analysis 41 New Mexico Indian Gaming Analysis 43 Oklahoma Indian Gaming Analysis 47 RubinBrown’s Hospitality & Gaming Services
Welcome from RubinBrown’s Hospitality and Gaming Partner-in-Charge RubinBrown’s Gaming Services Group is pleased to present the 2011 edition of Gaming Stats. As our presence within the gaming industry continues to expand, so has our publication. From the Commercial side, this year’s publication has been
expanded to include the state of Colorado. In addition, we expanded the analysis within electronic gaming devices and table games to include hold percentages by denomination and hold percentages by game type, respectively. With our continued expansion into Indian Country, we are excited to introduce a section specifically related to Tribal Gaming. We have highlighted statistics on a National and Regional level. We have also included detailed analysis for Arizona, Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, and Oklahoma. Thank you to the many gaming industry leaders for your support and insights. We hope our publication continues to prove to be a valuable comprehensive tool throughout the year. I personally welcome your feedback on this issue of Gaming Stats. Please feel free to email me directly at chelle.adams@rubinbrown.com.
Chelle F. Adams Partner-in-Charge Hospitality and Gaming Industry Group
DISCLAIMER: Gaming Stats, a publication of RubinBrown LLP, is designed to provide general information regarding the subject matter covered. Although prepared by professionals, its contents should not be construed as the rendering of advice regarding specific situations. If accounting, legal or other expert assistance is needed, consult with your professional business advisor. Please call RubinBrown with any questions (contact information is located on the back cover).
1 | Raise Your Expectations
Executive Summary
Introduction The RubinBrown Gaming Stats publication was created in order to provide a comprehensive and comparative report of key gaming statistics of commercial gaming operations (excluding racinos) in Colorado, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, and Missouri and tribal gaming operations in Arizona, Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, and Oklahoma. The statistics include high level national and regional comparisons as well as detailed state-by-state information of 2010 gross gaming revenues, tax contributions, admissions, electronic gaming devices, table games, and incident reports for the commercial and tribal casinos. Within the U.S., there are 458 commercial land-based and riverboat casinos in 14 states. The five states referenced in this publication comprise 25 percent of 2010 adjusted gross receipts of the 14 states with commercial gaming. Colorado and Missouri were the only two of the five states referenced that experienced an increase in gaming revenue in 2010. From a tribal perspective, there are 240 tribes operating 447 Class II and Class III casinos in 29 states. The five states referenced in this publication represent 36 percent of the Class II and Class III tribal casinos in the U.S. Information used to compile the statistics provided in the following pages was obtained from the state gaming regulatory authorities, the American Gaming Association, and the National Indian Gaming Commission (see page 48 for the complete listing of sources). General Industry Economic Update As our nation continues to feel the effects of the 2007 Great Recession, it is clear that the gaming industry is not recession proof. Operators and tribes have felt the impact of reduced consumer spending, mergers, bankruptcies, stricter lending requirements, and stalled capital projects. Although the gaming industry suffered their worst decline over the past three years, the rebound is starting to occur. Predictions anticipate it will take many years for the industry to recover to pre-2007 revenues. However, the gaming industry continues to expand through changes in gaming legalization, updates in technology, and expansion into new markets. Gaming dollars remain a strong source of revenue for states and tribes throughout the United States.
Tribal While Tribal gaming properties have been able to avoid the high tax rates imposed by state regulators, they have been challenged by a shortage of lenders within the capital markets. In early 2010, the Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. Lake of the Torches Economic Development Corporation decision brought into question the recourse available to lending institutions. Since this decision, lenders have severely limited or stopped lending to tribal gaming organizations based on the fear, that in the event of default, tribal sovereignty or the application of the Indian Gaming Regulation Act (IGRA) would limit the lender’s ability to recoup their investment. Beyond the lending climate, Tribal casinos continue to feel the impact of regional casino openings and increased competition. Major tribal operators continue to seek new opportunities in commercial gaming to boost their brands and leverage their loyalty programs.
www.rubinbrown.com | 2
National Comparison
Commercial Overall, the U.S. gaming industry continues to suffer, but stabilized in 2010 with a slight increase in adjusted gross receipts of .34% over 2009. The industry has not seen an increase in revenue in the past three years. However, as gaming revenues continue to stabilize, its popularity within state legislatures has increased. In 2010, numerous states have pushed for the expansion of gaming including such states as Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Maryland. While states see casinos as a path to balancing state budgets, existing commercial gaming operators have been challenged to find new ways to invest in their properties, amidst reduced revenues and burdensome tax rates that in some jurisdictions exceed 50% of gross gaming revenue. 2011 Industry Forecast Although not recession proof, the gaming industry is resilient. Improved economic conditions are predicted to trigger a recovery in late 2011. The industry will continue to see mergers, a strong focus on customer loyalty programs, and the expansion of non-gaming amenities such as entertainment venues, restaurants, spas, and golf courses to attract patrons to the casinos’ complete destination experience. Properties will rely on advances in technology such as server- based gaming, promotional coupons, and hand held wagering devices to appeal to Generation Y patrons. The consensus is that 2011 will be a turning point for the industry; however, the U.S. gaming industry will soon face a major challenge with the legalization of internet gaming in the U.S. on the rise.
Adjusted Gross Receipts by State (Millions)
2009
2010
% Change
Colorado
735
760
3.40% -4.06% -1.30% -1.59%
Illinois Indiana
1,429 2,379
1,371 2,348
Iowa
945
930
Kansas* Louisiana
2
38
1,800.00%
2,053
1,986
-3.26%
Maryland** Michigan Mississippi
NA
28
NA
1,339 2,465 1,730
1,378 2,390 1,788
2.91% -3.04% 3.35% 0.12% -9.59% 26.51% 3.92% 0.34%
Missouri Nevada
10,393
10,405
New Jersey Pennsylvania South Dakota
3,943 1,965
3,565 2,486
102
106
Total
$29,480
$29,579
*The first commercial Kansas Casino opened on December 15, 2009, therefore the percentage increase is not representative of a full year’s operations. **The first commercial Maryland casino opened September 27, 2010, therefore no information to report prior to 2010.
National – Percentage of Commercial Gaming Industry
MI 5%
IL 5%
IA 3%
CO 3%
MO 6%
KS, MD & SD <1%
PA 8%
LA 7%
NV 35%
IN 8%
MS 8%
NJ 12%
3 | Raise Your Expectations
State Gaming Tax Revenues
Commercial Gaming Tax Revenues by State
Consistent with overall commercial gaming revenues, state gaming tax revenues had mixed results in 2010. Of the 13 states that had commercial gaming in both 2009 and 2010, 7 states recorded increases and 6 states recorded declines in state tax revenues. However, most interesting is the fact that total taxes paid increased more than total revenue. In 2010 commercial gaming revenues increased by $99 million, or 0.34%, while the aggregate taxes paid increased by $182 million, or 3.41%. The larger increase in taxes paid is attributed to the substantial growth in states with higher tax rates, such as Pennsylvania. Prior to 2010, Pennsylvania claimed the highest tax rate with 55 percent of Electronic Gaming Device (EGD) revenues being paid to the state. In September, Maryland celebrated the opening of its first casino and began imposing a 67 percent tax rate on EGD revenues. In general, Midwest states impose a tax rate between 20-35 percent. Also noteworthy, only three of the 14 states charge an admissions tax on patrons entering the casino floor.
$1.3B
$867M
$433M
$0
Iowa
Illinois
Indiana
Nevada
Kansas*
Missouri
Michigan
Louisiana
Colorado
Mississippi
Maryland**
New Jersey
Pennsylvania
South Dakota
2009
2010
*The first commercial Kansas Casino opened on December 15, 2009, therefore the percentage increase is not representative of a full year’s operations. **The first commercial Maryland casino opened on September 27, 2010, therefore no information to report prior to 2010.
National – Commercial Gaming Tax Revenues
Gaming Revenue Tax Rate
Description of Gaming Tax Rates
Colorado
0.25 - 20% Graduated tax rate from .25% - 20%, with all adjusted gross proceeds in excess of $13 million taxed at 20%.
Illinois
15 - 50% Graduated tax rate from 15% - 50%, with all adjusted gross receipts in excess of $200 million taxed at 50%, plus an admission tax of $2 - $3 per patron per gaming day. 15 - 40% Graduated tax rate from 15% - 40%, with all adjusted gross receipts in excess of $600 million taxed at 40%, plus an admission tax of $3 per patron per gaming day. 27% Gross gaming revenue tax of 27%, with 22% paid to the state, 3% to the locality, and 2% to the state problem gambling fund. 21.5% Riverboats incur a tax rate of 21.5% of adjusted gross receipts with additional local taxes determined by locality. Land- based casinos incur the greater of 21.5% of adjusted gross receipts or $60 million. 67% Gross gaming revenue tax of 67% with 48.5% - 51% to the Maryland Education Trust Fund, 7% to horse racing purse account, 5.5% to local impact grants, 2.5% to race track facilities renewal account, 2% to Maryland Lottery, and 1.5% to small, minority and women-owned businesses. 19 - 24% Permanent facilities pay a flat tax of 19% on gross gaming revenue, while temporary facilities pay a flat tax rate of 24%. In 2010 the one pre-existing temporary facility was converted to a permanent facility. 4 - 8% Graduated tax rate from 4% - 8%, with all monthly adjusted gross receipts in excess of $134,000 taxed at 8%. Additional local taxes up to 4% of revenues, as well as annual licensing and gaming device taxes. 3.5 - 6.75% Graduated tax rate from 3.5% to 6.75%, with all monthly gross gaming revenue in excess of $134,000 taxed at 6.75%, with additional local, gaming devices, regulatory, and entertainment taxes. 9.25 - 10.5% Gross gaming revenue tax of 8% plus either a community investment alternative obligation tax of 1.25% or an investment alternative of 2.5%. An additional tax of 4.25% charged on Casino complimentaries. 16% and 55% A gross gaming revenue tax of 16% is imposed on all table games, with 14% paid to the state and 2% to the locality. A gross gaming revenue tax of 55% is imposed on all electronic gaming devices, with 34% applied to property tax relief, 12% to the horse racing industry, 5% to the Economic Development and Tourism Fund and 4% to local government. 5 - 22% Graduated tax rate from 5% - 22%, with all adjusted gross receipts in excess of $3 million taxed at 22%. 21% Adjusted gross receipts tax of 21%, plus an admissions tax of $2 per patron per excursion.
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Louisiana
Maryland
Michigan
Mississippi
Missouri
Nevada
New Jersey
Pennsylvania
South Dakota
8%
Gross gaming revenue tax of 8% plus an annual gaming device tax of $2,000 per machine per year.
www.rubinbrown.com | 4
Regional Comparison
Three Year Trend of Adjusted Gross Receipts
Consistent with national trends, regional gaming appears to have stabilized in 2010. The five dominant states within the region experienced a $21 million decline in revenues during 2010, which was much improved over the $74 million decline in 2009. On a state by state basis, Colorado and Missouri continued the trend of upward growth in gaming revenues. Their resiliency throughout the economic uncertainty has been attributed to favorable
$2.5B
$2B
$1.5B
$1B
$500M
$0 $0
Colorado
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
2008
2009
2010
legislation and continued economic investment by
commercial gaming operators. Meanwhile, Illinois, Indiana, and Iowa finished 2010 with modest
With regard to average square feet per property, the average Missouri and Indiana casinos are nearly twice the size of its neighboring states. This is primarily attributed to the industry finding ways to move away from the more traditional riverboat casino design to what appears to be a land based facility. This has also afforded Missouri and Indiana properties the ability to offer more table games and EGDs.
declines in revenues. Most notably, Illinois appears to be stabilizing from the 2007 smoking ban and economic downturn with only a 4.06% decline in revenues. While this was the largest decline in the region, it is much improved compared to the 8.91% and 20.91% declines in 2009 and 2008, respectively. When comparing the regional states, Indiana continues to be the dominant leader in overall revenues and casino size, while Colorado has the highest number of casinos. The disparity between the number of casinos in Colorado compared to the other states is due to Colorado limiting gaming to three specific cities and not imposing strict limitations on the number of gaming licenses in the state. Also noteworthy, the increased competition in Colorado is aided through the lowest effective tax rate in the region.
Comparison of Casinos by State
Colorado
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
2010 Gaming Revenues Number of Properties Casino Square Feet Average Square Feet
$759,610,323 $1,370,946,000 $2,348,451,170
$930,032,711 $1,787,915,041
37
9
11
14
12
391,824 10,590
322,335 35,815
710,113 64,556
409,862 29,276
774,800 64,567
Average Number of Table Games
8
26
68
25
44
Average Number of EGDs
407
1,144
1,754
914
1,646
Effective Tax Rate*
14.09%
34.00%
31.93%
21.95%
27.19%
*Effective tax rate accounts for adjustments to AGR, admission taxes, and graduated brackets.
5 | Raise Your Expectations
Regional Electronic Gaming Device Analysis While Illinois trails Indiana and Missouri in overall casino size, they lead the region in average revenue per gaming device. In 2010, Illinois recorded the highest AGR per EGD per day in the region with an average of $319.23. Interestingly, Illinois also had the second lowest hold percentage of 8.04%. However, while Illinois leads the region in revenue per EGD, their margin over neighboring states continues to decrease. In 2010, Illinois daily average revenue per EGD was only $24.84 greater
Electronic Gaming Device Analysis
$400.00
10.00%
8.00%
$266.67
6.00%
$133.33
4.00%
$0
Colorado
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
AGR per EGD per Day
Average EGD Hold
than Indiana, as compared to the $63.10 margin it claimed in 2009. Of the five states analyzed, Colorado had both the lowest average daily revenue per EGD and the lowest hold percentage. This is most likely indicative of the increased competition that exists within the Colorado market. Examining EGD hold percentages by denomination, the overall state comparison was consistent with the average hold. Colorado, having the lowest total average hold, was the lowest or second lowest in all denomination categories. Indiana and Missouri, having the highest total hold percentages, tended to have the highest EGD
hold by denomination, with only one exception. Missouri had the second lowest nickel hold percentage in 2010. Overall, the states exhibited the industry trend of the penny machines having a hold percentage between 10 – 12%, while the higher denominations had a hold percentage between 5 – 7%.
Electronic Gaming Device Hold Percentage by Denomination
12.00%
10.00%
8.00%
6.00%
4.00%
2.00%
0%
$0.01
$0.05
$0.25
$1.00
$5.00
Colorado
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
www.rubinbrown.com | 6
Regional Comparison – continued
Regional Table Games Analysis
Table Games Analysis
Similar to EGD revenues, Illinois led the region in average daily revenue per table game with an average of $2,006.84. In 2010, Colorado surpassed Iowa producing average daily revenue per table game of $672.88, as compared to $531.96 in 2009 (a 26.5% increase). The dramatic increase is attributed to 2010 being the first full year after Colorado increased
$3K
24.00%
$3K
$2K
18.00%
$2K
$1K
$1K
12.00%
the maximum allowed table game wager. The only other state to record an increase in average daily revenue per table game was Missouri, which recorded a 0.8% increase over 2009. Table hold percentages displayed an inverse relationship with the states having the lowest hold percentages producing the highest average daily revenue per table game. This inverse relationship is consistent with the trends noticed in prior years, as the lower hold percentage tends to keep players playing longer and ultimately losing more. Examining table game hold percentages by game type, the overall comparison of hold percentages remained consistent, with Colorado having the lowest hold in all four game types. The comparison of games reflected industry trends with Blackjack yielding the lowest hold of approximately 15%, while Roulette and Poker produced $0 $0
6.00%
Colorado
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
AGR per Table Game per Day
Average Table Game Hold
some of the highest hold percentages. In comparing the House Bet Poker games, there was significant fluctuation across the region, as the type of poker games varied from state to state. When analyzing the table game hold percentage, one must consider the varying factors, including population demographics and variations in game rules.
Table Game Hold Percentage by Game Type
30.00%
25.00%
20.00%
15.00%
10.00%
5.00%
0%
Blackjack
Craps
Roulette
House Bet Poker Games
Colorado
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
7 | Raise Your Expectations
www.rubinbrown.com | 8
Regional Comparison – continued
Regional Disciplinary Action The graph below categorizes the disciplinary actions taken by the Colorado Limited Gaming Commission, Indiana Gaming Commission, and the Missouri Gaming Commission. To provide a summary of the top disciplinary actions, the top 10 fines incurred have been listed. A linear relationship between the incident and the fine amount cannot be drawn as each fine is independently reviewed by state regulatory bodies. Overall, there were 77 fines levied by the three states related to 125 incidents. Incidents related to security oversight or failure was the most common occurrence with 47 individual incidents, equaling 38% of all incidents evaluated. While a direct correlation between incident and fine amount could not be determined, the highest fines related to systematic failures to comply with regulations associated with the treatment of intoxicated and underage patrons. • Missouri properties incurred a total of 43 fines related to 57 individual incidents, resulting in $885,000 in fines. The average per incident equals $15,526. Missouri
exhibited a high intolerance for failing to recognize egregiously intoxicated patrons and the admittance of underage patrons. • Indiana properties incurred a total of 26 fines related to 60 individual incidents, resulting in $291,500 in fines. The average fine per incident equals $4,858. Indiana’s most common incidents related to the failure to communicate with state regulators, admittance of underage patrons, and violations of rules designed to protect voluntarily excluded persons. • Colorado properties incurred a total of 8 fines related to 8 individual incidents, resulting in $59,750 in fines. The average fine per incident equals $8,536. The majority of the fines levied in Colorado related to unauthorized searches of the Gambling Payment Intercept registry or failure to timely report information to the Colorado Department of Child Support Enforcement. (Note: Detailed disciplinary information for Iowa and Illinois could not be summarized as the information was not readily available.)
Summary of Disciplinary Actions by Category
100% 100%
50
40
80% 80%
60% 60%
30
40% 40%
20
20% 20%
10
0%
0%
0
Table Game Operations
Reporting to State Gaming Commission
Cage Operations
EGD Operations
Improper Marketing Campaigns
Surveillance Operations
Count Room Operations
Security Operations
Number of Incidents
Cumulative Percentage
9 | Raise Your Expectations
Summary of Top Ten Disciplinary Action Fines
State
Fine Amount
# of Incidents Included in Fine
Incident Category
Incidents
1 Missouri
$75,000
1
- Security Operations
- An intoxicated patron was allowed to gamble, leave the casino floor, and depart the facility only to be stopped by three civilians. Surveillance tapes showed the patron falling down and showing signs of obvious intoxication in front of numerous personnel. - The illegal use of cocaine by two security shift managers while on duty along with the failure of multiple employees having knowledge of the incidents and repetitve failure to disclose the incidents. - Admittance of an underage patron to the casino floor, served the patron alcoholic beverages, and allowed the patron to gamble for over fifteen hours. During review of surveillance tapes it was determined that the under aged patron interacted with 33 casino personnel without being checked for an ID. The action was the result of multiple violations that included the following: - Casino failed to timely notify the Gaming agents of the termination of four employees - Casino allowed three underage people onto the casion floor - Violation of rule regarding playing card specifications - Violation of rule regarding storing and locking of chips - Casino did not follow the procedure submitted for a monthly promotion - An intoxicated person was permitted to continue gambling, leave the casino floor, and exit the facility, before being stopped by two security officers. There were ten violations that included the following eight incidents: - Main bank accountability sheets not including correct amounts - Cage being observed making exchanges without documentation - Audible alarms not sounding when redemption kiosks were open - Safe keeping receipts missing cage cashiers and patrons’ signature and not including patrons’ photos - Coupons not being scanned or manually input - Table games supervisor not inspecting dice for evidence of tampering at the end of the gaming day The disciplinary action was the result of multiple violations that included the following: - Admittance of an underage patron to the gaming floor - Violation of Voluntary Exclusion Program rules - Allowing an employee to work with an expired badge and untimley reporting of employee terminations - Continued to use the services of a supplier that failed to renew its license - Failure to disclose a substantial owner when applying for a gaming license The disciplinary action was the result of multiple violations that included the following: - Allowing an employee to work with an expired badge and untimley reporting of employee terminations - Admittance of an underage patron to the gaming floor - Table games jackpot slips not containing dealer signature - Patrons allowed in drop area during bill validator drops - Violation of sensitive key regulations - Violation of non-value chip regulations - Use of playing cards that did not meet state specifications - Permitting access to the inside of a slot machine - Admittance of an underage patron to the gaming floor, serving the patron alcohol and permitting the patron to gamble The disciplinary action was the result of multiple violations that included the following: - Failure to test a coin machine before placing it in service - Untimely reporting of employee terminations - Failure to require employees to wear gaming badges
2 Missouri
$75,000
1
- Security Operations
3 Missouri
$75,000
1
- Security Operations
4 Indiana
$70,000
5
- Security Operations - Table Game Operations - Reporting to State Gaming Commission
5 Missouri
$50,000
1
- Security Operations
6 Missouri
$50,000
10
- Table Game Operations - Cage Operations - Surveillance and Security Operations
7 Indiana
$49,000
5
- Security Operations - Marketing Operations - Reporting to the State Gaming Commission
8 Indiana
$36,500
6
- Reporting to the State Gaming Commission - Security Operations - Table Game Operations - EGD Operations
9 Missouri
$35,000
1
- Security Operations
10 Indiana
$31,500
1
- Reporting to the State Gaming Commission - EGD Operations - Table Game Operations - Cage Operations
- Violation of card storage regulations - Violation of found money regulations - Improper completion of chip transfers - Improper verification of funds
www.rubinbrown.com | 10
Regional Comparison – continued
Regional Patron and Casino Win Analysis Overall, the region saw 463,279 (0.6% increase) more patrons in 2010 as compared to 2009. Market share remained relatively stable across all states, with Indiana and Missouri increasing patron admissions. Looking at the individual markets, the St. Louis, Missouri market saw the largest increase in patrons, gaining 1.6 million more patrons in 2010. The market increase is attributed to the addition of a new property that lured patrons away from the two St. Louis, Illinois properties. In 2010, Iowa was the only state to increase the average casino win per patron, increasing from $58.09 in 2009 to $59.29 in 2010. Illinois was able to produce constant returns as the win per patron of $99.10 was the same as
last year. Meanwhile, the two states that saw increases in patrons experienced a decline in casino win per patron. Indiana recorded the largest percentage decrease of 1.68%. The state tax per patron varied with Illinois and Indiana benefitting the most from having the highest effective tax rates in the region. Overall, the regional gaming outlook remains positive with aggregate patrons and revenues increasing in 2010. With the continued economic recovery and ongoing expansion of gaming in Illinois, Iowa, and Missouri, it is anticipated that regional gaming will continue to grow in the coming years.
Regional – Patrons & Adjusted Gross Receipts
# of Casinos
Patrons
% of Total Patrons
Adjusted Gross Receipts
% of Total AGR
Illinois
Chicago Vicinity St. Louis Vicinity
4 2 3 9
7,090,487 3,081,170 3,662,577 13,834,234
8.5% $857,949,000 3.7% $205,801,000 4.4% $307,196,000 16.6% $1,370,946,000
13.3%
3.2% 4.8%
Other Communities
Illinois Total
21.3%
Indiana
Chicago Vicinity
5 3 3
14,761,173 4,864,061 6,919,393 26,544,627 6,518,008 3,027,416 6,139,624 15,685,048
17.7% $1,198,866,982 5.8% $473,419,173 8.3% $676,165,015 31.8% $2,348,451,170 7.8% $429,380,731 3.6% $175,240,485 7.4% $325,411,495 18.8% $930,032,711
18.6%
Southern Communities Ohio River Communities
7.4%
10.5% 36.5%
Indiana Total
11
Iowa Metropolitan Communities Mississippi River Communities
5 4 5
6.7% 2.7% 5.1%
Central Iowa Communities
Iowa Total
14
14.4%
Missouri
Kansas City Vicinity St. Louis Vicinity Other Communities
4
10,506,998 13,984,552 2,860,884 27,352,434
12.6% $714,140,125 16.8% $880,282,035 3.4% $193,492,881 32.8% $1,787,915,041
11.1% 13.7%
4*
4
3.0%
Missouri Total
12
27.8%
Region Total 100% *The Missouri St. Louis Vicinity operated with 5 casinos from March through June 2010, as River City Casino opened in March and the President Casino was closed in June 2010. 46 83,416,343 100% $6,437,344,922
11 | Raise Your Expectations
Three Year Trend of Patrons by State
30M 30
24M 24M
18M 18
12M 12
6M 6
0
0
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
2008
2009
2010
Casino Win and Tax per Patron
$40 $40
$100
$26 6
$67
$13 13
$33
$0 $0
$0
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
Casino Win per Patron
Revenue Tax Incurred per Patron
www.rubinbrown.com | 12
Colorado Gaming Statistics
In 1990, casino gaming was legalized in the state of Colorado, with three specific areas designated for development: Black Hawk, Central City, and Cripple Creek. Black Hawk is the largest area with 17 properties which generate 73.65% of the state’s gaming tax revenue. Central City is located one mile from Black Hawk and generates 17.7% of the state’s gaming tax revenue. Therefore, within a few mile radius, more than 90% of the state’s commercial gaming tax revenue is generated. Cripple Creek, located just west of Colorado Springs, creates the remaining 8.65% of commercial gaming tax revenue for the state.
Central City
Black Hawk
Cripple Creek
Colorado Gaming Statistics
Legalization Date
November 1990
First Casino Opening Date
October 1991
Current Number of Commercial Gaming Properties
37
2010 Commercial Casino Revenue
$759,610,323
2010 Commercial Gaming Tax Revenue
$107,020,950
Black Hawk
Cripple Creek
Central City
% of Statewide Revenues
73.65%
17.70%
8.65%
% of Statewide Gaming Devices
57.78%
27.08%
15.14%
Properties
Ameristar
Billy's Casino
Century Casino
Black Hawk Station
Brass Ass Casino
Doc Holliday Casino II Dostal Alley Saloon & Gambling Emporium
Bull Durham Saloon & Casino
Bronco Billy's Sports Bar & Casino
Bullwhackers Casino
Buffalo Billy's Casino
Easy Street
Canyon Casino
Century Casino Cripple Creek
The Famous Bonanza
Fitzgeralds's
Century Casinos
Fortune Valley Hotel & Casino
Gilpin Hotel Casino
Colorado Grande Casino
Johnny Z's Casino
Golden Gates Casino
Double Eagle Hotel & Casino
Golden Gulch Casino
Gold Creek Casino
Grand Plateau Casino
Johnny Nolon's
Isle of Capri Casino
J.P. McGill's
Lady Luck Casino Midnight Rose Hotel & Casino The Lodge Casino at Black Hawk Wildwood Casino at Cripple Creek Mardi Gras Red Dolly Casino, Inc.
Riviera Black Hawk Wild Card Saloon
13 | Raise Your Expectations
The total revenue for Cripple Creek casinos suffered in 2010 due to the closing of two properties, Gold Rush and Imperial Casino Hotel. Black Hawk and Central City improved their revenues, in part due to the opening of a new casino, Johnny Z’s, in Central City, and the enactment of Amendment 50. allowed the maximum bet at Colorado casinos to be raised from $5 to $100. The amendment also allowed casinos to include additional table games, such as craps and roulette, along with the permitting properties to remain open 24 hours a day. The new maximum bets and extended operating hours went into effect on July 2, 2009. With 2010 being the first full year of the amendment’s enactment, casino revenue increased Amendment 50 was passed by Colorado voters in 2009, which
Adjusted Gross Proceeds by Region
$600M
$400M
$200M
$0
Black Hawk
Central City
Cripple Creek
2008
2009
2010
Table Games Adjusted Gross Proceeds by Region
$70M
3.4% in 2010, compared to 2009 revenues, in spite of the country’s recession.
$47M
$23M
$0
Black Hawk
Central City
Cripple Creek
2008
2009
2010
www.rubinbrown.com | 14
Colorado Gaming Statistics – continued
Electronic Gaming Device Analysis
The casinos in Black Hawk have the highest EGD and table game AGR on average amongst the Colorado casinos. EGDs in Black Hawk acquired $156.59 of AGR per day on average. Central City casinos produced a hold percentage of 8.91% for $.50 slots which was the highest on average of their EGDs. Black Hawk and Cripple Creek casinos’ $.01 slots produced the highest hold of EGDs on average (9.71% and 8.21%).
$160.00
7.10%
$106.67
6.77%
$53.33
6.43%
$0
6.10%
Black Hawk
Central City
Cripple Creek
AGR per EGD per Day
Average EGD Hold
Electronic Gaming Device Hold Percentage by Denomination
10.00%
8.33%
6.67%
5.00%
3.33%
1.67%
0%
$0.01
$0.05
$0.25
$0.50
$1.00
$5.00
$25.00
Black Hawk
Central City
Cripple Creek
15 | Raise Your Expectations
Table Games Analysis
Table Games in Black Hawk received $882.83 of AGR per day on average. Black Hawk’s AGR per day for table games and for EGDs is double the average of table game and EGD AGRs for Central City and Cripple Creek. Across the Colorado casinos in Black Hawk, Central City, and Cripple Creek, roulette produced the highest hold percentage amongst table games on average (24.27%, 24.55%, 27.36%).
$1K
24.00%
$666.67
20.00%
16.00%
$333.33
12.00%
$0
Black Hawk
Central City
Cripple Creek
AGR per Table Game per Day
Average Table Game Hold
Table Game Hold Percentage by Game Type
30.00%
25.00%
20.00%
15.00%
10.00%
5.00%
0%
House Bet Poker
Blackjack
Craps
Roulette
Black Hawk
Central City
Cripple Creek
www.rubinbrown.com | 16
Illinois Gaming Statistics
Illinois saw revenues from riverboat gaming fall to their lowest levels in a decade in 2010. While revenues from horse racing and lotteries remained flat, commercial gaming revenues fell by 4.06%. Overall gaming admissions declined by 4.05% as well. A stagnant economy, increased competition in the St. Louis market and the 2007 ban on smoking in Illinois’ commercial gaming properties continue to negatively affect revenues. While revenues and patron levels continue to decline, the State Legislature continues to look for new ways to generate gaming tax revenues. Late in 2010, the Illinois State Senate proposed and passed gambling expansion legislation that would have cleared the way for several new land based casinos located in Chicago, Park City, Rockford, Danville, and southern Cook County.
Grand Victoria Casino
Hollywood Casino
Harrah’s Joliet
Empress
Jumers
Par-A-Dice
Argosy
Casino Queen
Harrah’s Metropolis
Illinois Gaming Statistics
Legalization Date
February 1990
First Casino Opening Date
September 1991
Current Number of Commercial Gaming Properties
9
2010 Commercial Gaming Admissions
13,834,234
2010 Commercial Casino Revenue
$1,370,946,000
2010 Commercial Gaming Tax Revenue
$466,092,093
City
Gaming Square Feet
% of Statewide Revenues
% of Statewide Admissions
Chicago Vicinity Empress
Joliet Elgin Joliet
50,000 29,850 39,000 41,384
10.46% 20.94% 17.98% 13.20% 62.58%
9.15%
Grand Victoria Casino
15.35% 16.00% 10.76% 51.26%
Harrah’s
Hollywood Casino
Aurora
Chicago Vicinity Total
160,234
St. Louis Vicinity Argosy
Alton
23,000 40,000 63,000
5.64% 9.37%
7.48%
Casino Queen
East St. Louis
14.79% 22.27%
St. Louis Vicinity Total
15.01%
Other Communities Harrah’s
Metropolis Rock Island
30,985 42,000 26,116 99,101
8.21% 5.79% 8.41%
7.03% 9.99% 9.45%
Jumers
Par-A-Dice
Peoria
Other Communities Total
22.41%
26.47%
17 | Raise Your Expectations
This legislation would have also allowed Illinois’ licensed horse racing facilities to operate 6,300 electronic gaming devices on their properties. The bill met heavy opposition from the existing properties and was slated to be voted on in the Illinois House at the end of the 2010 legislative session. However, the bill was never called to the floor for a vote by the Speaker of the House and the measure was essentially rejected without ever coming to a vote. In July of 2011, Illinois will see its tenth commercial gaming facility open its doors in Des Plaines, a western suburb of Chicago. The 147,000 square-foot complex will include a 43,000 square-foot casino with 1,200 gambling positions, including a high limit area. Almost a decade in the making, the as-yet-to- be-named facility will be located near Chicago’s O’Hare airport and is expected to generate $150 million in annual tax revenue in addition to creating over 1,000 new, permanent jobs. Regionally, Illinois’ Chicago area casinos continue to show significantly higher AGR per square foot and AGR per patron figures than their competition directly across the state line in Indiana. Chicago market casinos saw their AGR and admissions decrease in 2010. Only the newly named Hollywood Casino (formally the Empress) in Joliet saw significant increases in AGR and admissions during 2010. The increases recognized by the Hollywood Casino are attributed to a dismal 2009 where the facility temporarily closed for three months due to fire damage that occurred during renovations.
Adjusted Gross Receipts by Region
$1.1B
$733M
$367M
$0
Chicago Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
2008
2009
2010
Adjusted Gross Receipts Analysis
$6K
$130.00
$86.67
$4K
$2K
$43.33
$0
$0
Chicago Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
AGR per Square Foot
AGR per Patron
www.rubinbrown.com | 18
Illinois Gaming Statistics – continued
Electronic Gaming Device Analysis
The Chicago vicinity saw average AGR per EGD per day decrease by 8.72% while the average EGD hold increased from 8.04% to 8.29%. Average AGR per table game and average table holds remained fairly stable during 2010. Illinois casinos in the St. Louis region saw revenue and admissions figures continue to decline sharply in 2010. This region saw average hold for both EGD and table games increase substantially over 2009, while average AGR per EGD per day and average AGR per table game per day decreased by 10.89% and 9.97%, respectively. The declines in the St. Louis market are attributable to the impact of Pinnacle Entertainment opening the River City casino in the southern suburbs of St. Louis.
$600.00
9.00%
$333.33
6.00%
$166.67
3.00%
$0
0%
Chicago Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
AGR per EGD per Day
Average EGD Hold
Electronic Gaming Device Hold Percentage by Denomination
13.00%
10.83%
8.67%
6.50%
4.33%
2.17%
0%
$0.01
$0.05
$0.25
$0.50
$1.00
$5.00
$25.00
Chicago Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
19 | Raise Your Expectations
Commercial gaming properties in smaller communities in Illinois
Table Games Analysis
experienced varying degrees of success in 2010, with the overall classification recognizing a 1.32% increase in revenues, as aggregated revenue and admission data stayed fairly stable. The Par-A-Dice casino in Peoria saw annual AGR remain relatively unchanged even as admissions decreased by 2.06%, while significant decreases in annual AGR and admissions at Harrah’s Metropolis were offset by large AGR and admission increases at Jumer’s Casino in Rock Island. Illinois’ small market casinos were the only region to see increases in average AGR per EGD per day and average AGR per table game per day, while also being the only region to have a decrease in average EGD and table game hold percentages.
$4K
20.00%
18.33%
$3K
$1K
16.67%
16.00%
$0
Chicago Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
AGR per Table Game per Day
Average Table Game Hold
Table Game Hold Percentage by Game Type
30.00%
25.00%
20.00%
15.00%
10.00%
5.00%
0%
Caribbean Stud Poker
Blackjack
Craps
Roulette
Three Card Poker
Other House Bet Poker
Chicago Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
www.rubinbrown.com | 20
Indiana Gaming Statistics
After experiencing a smaller downturn than many of the worst hit states in 2009, Indiana saw its gaming revenues decline again in 2010, by a marginal 1.27%. Indiana also saw its overall admissions decline by 0.4% in 2010 following a 4% increase in patronage in 2009. After seeing major capital improvements to many facilities in prior years, capital expenditures involving existing commercial gaming properties in Indiana were minimal. In 2009, the Indiana General Assembly commissioned a Gaming Study Committee to investigate several issues surrounding commercial gaming in Indiana, including the potential impact of increased outside competition from neighboring states. The commission expressed several findings which included the following:
Majestic Star II
Blue Chip
Ameristar
Majestic Star
Horseshoe - Hammond
Grand Victoria Hollywood Casino
French Lick
Belterra
Horseshoe - Elizabeth
Casino Aztar
Indiana Gaming Statistics
Legalization Date
November 1993
First Casino Opening Date
December 1995
Current Number of Commercial Gaming Properties
11
2010 Commercial Gaming Admissions
26,544,627
2010 Commercial Casino Revenue
$2,348,451,170
2010 Commercial Gaming Tax Revenue
$749,802,694
City
Gaming Square Feet
% of Statewide Revenues
% of Statewide Admissions
Chicago Vicinity Ameristar Blue Chip Horseshoe Majestic Star Majestic Star II
East Chicago Michigan City
53,492 65,000 108,000 43,000 40,261 309,753
10.43% 7.58% 23.78%
11.41% 9.67% 23.15% 5.69% 5.69% 55.61%
Hammond
Gary Gary
4.82% 4.44%
Chicago Vicinity Total
51.05%
Southern Communities Casino Aztar
Evansville French Lick
38,360 45,200 86,600
4.89% 3.47% 11.80% 20.16% 6.02% 4.16% 18.61% 28.79%
4.78% 3.97% 9.57%
French Lick Horseshoe
Elizabeth
Southern Communities
170,160
18.32%
Total
Ohio River Communities Belterra
Florence Rising Sun
40,200 40,000 150,000 230,200
6.35% 5.03% 14.69% 26.07%
Grand Victoria
Hollywood Ohio River
Lawrenceburg
Communities Total
21 | Raise Your Expectations
Adjusted Gross Receipts by Region
The Blue Chip Casino and Resort, which opened in 2009, saw 30% of its potential revenue siphoned off by the Four Winds Casino located in New Buffalo, Michigan. The Blue Chip also faces increased competition over existing revenues from both the Michigan based Firekeepers and Gun Lakes tribal casinos. If granted licenses, new casinos in both Gary and Fort Wayne, Indiana could significantly decrease revenues to neighboring commercial gaming properties in Indiana, but net tax revenue would likely increase for the state. Indiana may be better able to compete with out-of-state gaming facilities if riverboats were allowed to convert to land based gaming operations. If riverboat casinos were allowed to convert to land based operations, the commission concluded that these casinos should be required to maintain operations within the same municipality in which they currently reside.
$1.3B
$867M
$433M
$0
Chicago Vicinity
Southern Communities
Ohio River Communities
2008
2009
2010
Adjusted Gross Receipts Analysis
$4K
$100.00
$3K
$90.00
$80.00
$1K
$0
$70.00
Chicago Vicinity
Southern Communities
Ohio River Communities
AGR per Square Foot
AGR per Patron
www.rubinbrown.com | 22
Indiana Gaming Statistics – continued
Electronic Gaming Device Analysis
The Chicago area casinos saw their overall AGR for the fiscal year remain essentially identical to that of 2009, while their EGD and table holds remained fairly constant as well. The Chicago based casinos also held higher AGR per square foot, AGR per EGD, and AGR per table game ratios than both the Ohio River and Southern Communities, but, as is typical of gaming operations in larger metropolitan regions, the Chicago region had the lowest AGR per patron. Even though admissions were down by 4.13%, the Ohio River Community casinos (near Cincinnati, Ohio) only saw their AGR decrease by 2.18% from 2009 to 2010. In 2011, these properties will look to continue to instill patron loyalty and prepare for the expansion of gaming in Ohio. During 2010, Ohio selected a partnership group between Dan Gilbert and Caesar’s Entertainment to construct a Horseshoe branded casino in downtown Cincinnati. The Ohio based casino is not anticipated to open until late 2012, providing time for the Indiana casino industry to plan for the increased competition.
$300
11.00%
7.33%
$200
$100
3.67%
$0
0%
Chicago Vicinity
Southern Communities
Ohio River Communities
AGR per EGD per Day
Average EGD Hold
Electronic Gaming Device Hold Percentage by Denomination
13.00%
10.83%
8.67%
6.50%
4.33%
2.17%
0%
$0.01
$0.05
$0.25
$0.50
$1.00
$5.00
$25.00
Chicago Vicinity
Southern Communities
Ohio River Communities
23 | Raise Your Expectations
Table Games Analysis
Examining EGD and table games during 2010, the Ohio River Communities casinos experienced declines in both average revenues per EGD and table game. However, the hold percentages for EGDs and table games moved in opposite directions. In 2010, the average EGD hold percentage decreased from 13.17% to 10.22%, while the average table game hold percentage rose from 19.56% to 20.91%. Nonetheless, the region still recorded the highest hold percentages when compared to the other two Indiana regions. Consistent with the rest of Indiana, the Southern Indiana Communities saw a 3.28% and 5.41% decline in revenues and admissions, respectively. Casinos in Southern Indiana Communities also had the lowest EGD hold of each of the State’s regions for the second straight year. In 2010, the region recognized an average hold of 7.38%, as compared to 9.02% in 2009.
$1.8K
21.00%
$1.2K
19.33%
$600
17.67%
16.00%
$0
Chicago Vicinity
Southern Communities
Ohio River Communities
AGR per Table Game per Day
Average Table Game Hold
Table Game Hold Percentage by Game Type
40.00%
33.33%
26.67%
20.00%
13.33%
6.67%
0%
Blackjack
Craps
Poker
Roulette
Baccarat
Chicago Vicinity
Southern Communities
Ohio River Communities
www.rubinbrown.com | 24
Made with FlippingBook flipbook maker