RubinBrown Gaming Stats 2010
Welcome to the 2017 edition of RubinBrown’s Gaming Statistics publication, which provides a comprehensive review of the United States gaming industry.
Commercial Gaming Stats
2010
A Publication of RubinBrown LLP
Executive Summary
Introduction RubinBrown is pleased to introduce the first edition of the Commercial Gaming Stats. As the recession has taken its toll on the U.S. and tourism has dropped, gaming in the Midwest has surprisingly held steady and, in some cases, even thrived as demonstrated by the opening of new properties and the expansion of existing facilities. comprehensive and comparative report of key gaming statistics of commercial gaming operations (excluding racinos) in Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, and Missouri. The statistics include high level national and regional comparisons as well as detailed state-by-state information of 2009 gross gaming revenues, tax contributions, admissions, electronic gaming devices, table games, and incident reports for the Midwest commercial casinos. Within the U.S., there are 445 commercial land-based and riverboat casinos in 13 states. The four Midwest states referenced in this publication comprise 22 percent of the 2009 adjusted gross receipts of the 13 states with commercial gaming. Missouri was only one of three states that experienced an increase in gaming revenue in 2009. Information used to compile the statistics provided in the following pages was obtained from the state gaming regulatory authorities and the American Gaming Association (please see page 17 for the complete listing). The RubinBrown Hospitality & Gaming Industry Group is proud to present this valuable reference tool. We encourage gaming operators and regulators to use these statistics as one of many tools in benchmarking and evaluating gaming operations. The Commercial Gaming Stats was created in order to provide a
Contents 1 Executive Summary 2 National Comparison 3 State Gaming Tax Revenues 4 Regional Comparison 9 Illinois Gaming Statistics 11 Indiana Gaming Statistics 13 Iowa Gaming Statistics 15 Missouri Gaming Statistics 17 RubinBrown’s Hospitality & Gaming Services
General Industry Economic Update Just a few years ago, Las Vegas was the center of growth for the hospitality and gaming industry, with increasing gaming revenues and hotel occupancies in excess of 95 percent. Today, the majority of the construction projects in Las Vegas sit incomplete and under bankruptcy protection or on an indefinite suspension. In contrast, casinos within the Midwest have seen continued economic investment despite the recession. Capital projects continue and revenues have increased because travelers are choosing to stay closer to home instead of traveling to bigger destinations. In addition, the increased legalization of commercial gaming has presented new challenges to existing commercial and tribal casinos as they are faced with more competition while trying to continue to enhance revenue. While the scenarios differ by property, jurisdiction and tribe, properties that succeed will share three common traits: • Strong patron loyalty through services and reward programs that exceed patron expectations • Leadership in technological innovation that improves the patron experience and reduces expenses incurred by the property • Commitment to a philosophy of continuous improvement of internal
processes while complying with stringent regulatory oversight
Overall, growth is expected to be focused on the creation of new regional markets and expanding those that already exist.
1 | Raise Your Expectations
National Comparison
Adjusted Gross Receipts by State (Millions)
In 2009, the U.S. gaming industry continued to struggle with revenues down 6.46 percent from 2008. The most significant declines were felt in formerly robust states like Nevada and New Jersey, which suffered double digit reductions in revenue. Only three of the 13 states with legalized commercial gaming experienced gains in 2009, due primarily to changes in restrictive gaming regulations such as the elimination of wager or loss limits. A number of states have legalized gaming in order to overcome budget deficits and increase tax revenue. The trend of increased legalization is expected to continue as more states benefit financially from commercial gaming. Recent gaming legalization includes: • Delaware – Sports Books • Illinois - Video gaming terminals at licensed establishments (bars and truck stops) • Kansas – Opened first Commercial Gaming property • Maryland – Slot Parlors From a market share perspective, Nevada continues to dominate the landscape with more than one-third of the market. The east coast dominance currently owned by New Jersey could be challenged in the coming years by Pennsylvania’s current and proposed growth. • Ohio – Commercial Gaming • Pennsylvania – Table Games
2009
2008
% Change
Colorado
735
716
2.65% -8.92% -3.41% -0.84% -6.17% -1.54% -9.41% 2.85% -10.40% -13.25% 21.60% -0.04% -6.45% NA
Illinois Indiana
1,429 2,379
1,569 2,463
Iowa
945
953 NA
Kansas* Louisiana Michigan Mississippi
2
2,053 1,339 2,465 1,730
2,188 1,360 2,721 1,682
Missouri Nevada
10,393
11,599
New Jersey Pennsylvania South Dakota
3,943 1,965
4,545 1,616
102
102
Total
$29,480
$31,514
*The first commercial Kansas casino opened on December 15, 2009, therefore there is no information to report prior to 2009.
National – Percentage of Gaming Industry
MI 5%
IL 5%
IA 3%
CO 2%
MO 6%
KS & SD <1%
PA 7%
LA 7%
NV 36%
IN 8%
MS 8%
NJ 13%
www.rubinbrown.com | 2
State Gaming Tax Revenues
Gaming Tax Revenues by State
States with established gaming operations struggled as a whole (i.e. MO, CO, PA increased) in 2009 with decreased tax revenue from gaming operations. In fact, from 2008 to 2009, most states suffered losses in their gaming tax revenues. The gaming tax rates vary widely by state. Pennsylvania has the highest rate of 55 percent while Nevada has the lowest tax rate of 6.75 percent. In general, Midwest states report a rate between 20-35 percent. Also noteworthy, only three of the 13 states charge an admissions tax on patrons entering the casino floor.
2008
2009
$1.2B
$800M
$400M
$0
Iowa
Illinois
Indiana
Nevada
Kansas*
Missouri
Michigan
Louisiana
Colorado
Mississippi
New Jersey
*The first Kansas casino opened on December 15, 2009, therefore there is no information to report prior to 2009.
Pennsylvania
South Dakota
National – Tax Revenues
State
Effective Gaming Revenue Tax Rate
Description of Gaming Tax Rates
Colorado
0.25 - 20% Graduated tax rate from .25% - 20%, with all adjusted gross proceeds in excess of $13 million taxed at 20%. 15 - 50% Graduated tax rate from 15% - 50%, with all adjusted gross receipts in excess of $200 million taxed at 50%, plus an admission tax of $2 - $3 per patron per gaming day. 15 - 40% Graduated tax rate from 15% - 40%, with all adjusted gross receipts in excess of $600 million taxed at 40%, plus an admission tax of $3 per patron per gaming day.
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
5 - 22%
Graduated tax rate from 5% - 22%, with all adjusted gross receipts in excess of $3 million being taxed at 22%. Gross gaming revenue tax of 27% with 22% being paid to the state, 3% to the locality, and 2% to the state problem gambling fund. Riverboats incur a tax rate of 21.5% of adjusted gross receipts with additional local taxes determined by locality. Land-based casinos incur the greater of 21.5% of adjusted gross receipts or $60 million.
Kansas
27%
Louisiana
21.5%
Michigan
19 - 24% Permanent facilities pay a flat tax of 19% on gross gaming revenue, while temporary facilities pay a flat tax rate of 24%.
Mississippi
4 - 8%
Graduated tax rate from 4% - 8%, with all adjusted gross receipts in excess of $134,000 taxed at 8%. Additional local taxes up to 4% of revenues, as well as annual licensing and gaming device taxes. Adjusted gross receipts tax of 21%, plus an admissions tax of $2 per patron per excursion.
Missouri Nevada
21%
3.5 - 6.75% Graduated tax rate from 3.5% to 6.75%, with all monthly gross gaming revenue in excess of $134,000 taxed at 6.75%, with additional local, gaming devices, regulatory, and entertainment taxes. 9.25 - 10.5% Gross gaming revenue tax of 8% plus either a community investment alternative obligation tax of 1.25% or an investment alternative of 2.5%. An additional tax of 4.25% charged on Casino complimentaries.
New Jersey
Pennsylvania South Dakota
55%
Gross terminal revenue tax rate of 55%.
8%
Gross gaming revenue tax of 8% plus an annual gaming device tax of $2,000 per machine per year.
3 | Raise Your Expectations
Regional Comparision
Three Year Trend of Adjusted Gross Receipts
While traditional gaming states have seen revenues drop significantly
in the last few years, casinos throughout the Midwest have weathered the recession with mixed results as gaming has
$3B
$2.25B
become more regionally focused. As noted in the graph, Iowa and Missouri have remained relatively stable or seen modest increases, while Illinois and Indiana have been impacted more adversely. Where there has been growth in regional gaming, it has been a product of the economy forcing consumers to stay closer to home, increased legalization, and the construction of “Vegas-style” casinos within regional communities.
$1.5B
$750M
$0
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
2007
2008
2009
Regional – Patrons & Adjusted Gross Receipts
# of Casinos
Patrons
% of Total Patrons
Adjusted Gross Receipts
% of Total AGR
Illinois
Chicago Vicinity St. Louis Vicinity
4 2 3 9
7,351,319 3,401,037 3,666,404 14,418,760
9% $893,973,000 4% $231,743,000 5% $303,201,000 18% $1,428,917,000
14%
3% 5%
Other Communities
Illinois Total
22%
Indiana
Chicago Vicinity
5 3 3
14,077,898 7,216,498 5,142,599 26,436,995 6,800,217 3,281,986 6,187,547 16,269,750
17% $1,198,101,091 9% $691,199,919 6% $489,456,251 32% $2,378,757,261 8% $443,067,736 4% $178,811,640 7% $323,240,141 19% $945,119,517
18% 11%
Southeastern Indiana Ohio River Communities
7%
Indiana Total
11
36%
Iowa Metropolitan Communities Mississippi Communities Central Iowa Communities
5 4 5
7% 3% 5%
Iowa Total
14
15%
Missouri
Kansas City Vicinity St. Louis Vicinity Other Communities
4 4 4
10,669,302 12,344,023 2,814,234 25,827,559
13% $719,923,380 15% $818,709,540 3% $191,682,841 31% $1,730,315,761
11% 13%
3%
Missouri Total
12
27%
Midwest Region Total
46
82,953,064
100% $6,483,109,539
100%
www.rubinbrown.com | 4
Regional Comparision – continued
Detailed Analysis of Casinos
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
Number of Properties Casino Square Feet Average Square Feet
9
11
14
12
322,335 35,815
710,113 64,556
409,862 29,276
774,800 64,567
Average Number of Table Games
26
68
25
44
Average Number of EGDs
1,119
1,766
923
1,077
Effective Tax Rate*
34.67%
32.06%
21.94%
27.11%
*Effective tax rate accounts for adjustments to AGR, admission taxes, and graduated brackets.
Three Year Trend of Patrons by State
Regional gaming has benefited from the economic downturn as consumers spend less on travel. Patron attendance increased in 2009 for most Midwest states, with the exception of Illinois, which has been adversely effected by legislative acts and an increase in gaming in neighboring states. With regard to average casino square feet, note that both Missouri and Indiana are much larger than Illinois and Iowa. This is primarily due to the high number of table games in those states. Illinois possesses the highest casino win per patron at $99.10, while Iowa’s casino win per patron is 41% lower at $58.09. Overall, the outlook for future growth in the Midwest appears positive. As more states look to reduce deficits and gain tax revenue, it is anticipated that regional gaming will increase in future years.
30M
24M
18M
12M
6M
0
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
2007
2008
2009
Casino Win and Tax per Patron
$100
$40.00
$99.10
$89.98
$34.36
$67
$26.67
$28.85
$66.99
$58.09
$18.16
$33
$13.33
$12.74
$0
$0
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
Casino Win per Patron
Revenue Tax Incurred per Patron
5 | Raise Your Expectations
Regional Electronic Gaming Devices & Table Game Analysis Illinois has the highest adjusted gross receipts (AGR) in relation to their electronic gaming devices (EGD) and table games (TG). However, it is ranked lower than Indiana in total gaming revenues. Of the four states analyzed, Iowa has the lowest AGR and number of electronic gaming device and table games in the region. The electronic gaming device hold is relatively consistent between the four states, with a spread of 2.3 percent. Illinois reports the lowest electronic gaming device hold at 7.8 percent. Overall, there is an inverse relationship between table hold and AGR per day. However, the AGR per table is impacted by other factors including population demographics and propensity to spend.
Electronic Gaming Devices Analysis
10.10%
$400
11.00%
9.03%
8.92%
$341.16
$266
7.33%
$278.06
7.80%
$216.86
$184.05
$133
3.67%
0%
$0
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
AGR per EGD per Day
Average EGD Hold
Table Games Analysis
21.41%
21.33%
$3K
22.00%
19.33%
17.33%
$2K
14.67%
$2,033.86
$1,495.96
$1K
7.33%
$1,038.86
$599.60
0%
$0
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Missouri
AGR per Table Game per Day
Average Table Game Hold
www.rubinbrown.com | 6
Regional Comparision – continued
Regional Disciplinary Action The graph and table depict the disciplinary actions reported in the Missouri and Indiana Gaming Board meeting minutes. To provide a summary of the disciplinary actions taken by these two states, the incidents have been summarized by category and the top 10 fines incurred have been listed. A linear relationship between the incident and fine amount cannot be drawn as each fine is independently reviewed by state regulatory bodies.
• Indiana properties reported a total of 52 incidents resulting in $408,200 in fines. The average fine per incident equals $7,850. • Missouri properties reported a total of 34 incidents resulting in $240,000 in fines. The average fine per incident equals $7,058.
Note: Detailed disciplinary action information for Iowa and Illinois could not be summarized as the information was not readily available. • Illinois incidents and disciplinary actions were not readily available in
the meeting minutes with the exception of one fine. A
property was fined $100,000 related to casino personnel being restricted from discussing confidential matters with gaming enforcement agents.
Summary of Disciplinary Actions by Category
Number of Incidents
Cumulative Percentage
100%
40
80%
32
60%
24
16
40%
20%
8
0
0%
Security Operations
EGD Operations
Table Game Operations
Information Technology
Reporting to Onsite Gaming Officers
Communication Between Departments
Improper Marketing Campaigns
Reporting to State Gaming Commission
Count Room Operations
7 | Raise Your Expectations
Summary of Top Ten Disciplinary Action Fines
State
Fine Amount $124,000
# of Incidents Included in Fine
Incident Category
Incidents
1)
Indiana
5
- Reporting to Onsite Gaming Officers - Improper Marketing Campaigns
- Failure to notify gaming enforcement agents of altercation - Ordered gaming software not approved by the state regulatory board - Filed incorrect tax form - Removed EGD from service without notifying the gaming commission - False advertising related to celebrities attending grand opening ceremonies - Seven underage individuals gained access to the casino floor within one month - Violated rules related to the inspection of playing cards - Two underage individuals gained access to the casino floor - Unused playing cards left unsecured - Table fill procedures improperly followed - Three violations of sensitive key rules - Violation of solicitation of tips by personnel in supervisory position - Casino allowed licensee to work with expired badge - Gaming enforcement agents were not notified of employee terminations on a timely basis - Violations of opening table game balances - Violation of access to sensitive keys - Failure to timely report criminal activity to gaming enforcement agents - Underage individuals gained access to casino floor - Tip box was unsecured and defective - EGD reconciliation was not performed for one gaming day - Underage individuals gained access to casino floor - Violation of internal controls concerning rakes not exceeding ten percent of all sums wagered in a pot - Failure to report information to the gaming commission, resulting in an incorrect progressive amount - Violation of dedicated coverage on a progressive jackpot - Violation of sensitive key rules - Violation of allowing only authorized personnel to have access to assets - Untimely reporting to the commission of incidents that the licensee believes to be a violation of the law or control standards - Sold liquor to intoxicated persons
2)
Missouri
$70,000
7
- Security Operations
3)
Indiana
$40,000
4
- Table Game Operations - Security Operations
4)
Indiana
$27,500
5
- Security Operations
5)
Indiana
$26,500
4
- Reporting to Onsite Gaming Officers - Table Game Operations - Security
6)
Indiana
$26,500
3
- Reporting to Onsite Gaming Officers - Table Game Operations - EGD Operations - Security Operations - Table Game Operations
7)
Indiana
$26,500
2
8)
Missouri
$25,000
1
- Reporting to the State Gaming Commission
9)
Indiana
$22,500
3
- Security Operations
10) Missouri
$20,000
2
- Reporting to the State Gaming Commission - Security Operations
www.rubinbrown.com | 8
Illinois Gaming Statistics
Overall in 2009, Illinois-based casinos experienced a decline in AGR of nearly 9 percent. The Chicago market’s decline was even more severe at 14 percent. Smaller Illinois communities experienced an 8 percent increase over 2008. The overall decline in Illinois is attributed to the struggling economy, the continued negative impact of the smoking ban, and increased competition from Missouri properties with the repeal of Missouri’s loss limit in November 2008.
On the legislative front, the need to generate greater tax revenues led to the enactment of the Video Gaming Act in July 2009. This legislation legalized video gaming terminals at licensed establishments such as bars and truck stops (up to five terminals in each). However, the act also provided counties and municipalities the option to ban the devices in their communities.
Grand Victoria Casino
Hollywood Casino
Harrah’s Joliet
Empress
Jumers
Par-A-Dice
Argosy
Casino Queen
Harrah’s Metropolis
Illinois Gaming Statistics
Legalization Date
February 1990
First Casino Opening Date
September 1991
Current Number of Commercial Gaming Properties
9
2009 Commercial Gaming Admissions
14,418,760
2009 Commercial Casino Revenue
$1,428,917,000
2009 Commercial Gaming Tax Revenue
$495,385,167
City
Gaming Square Feet
% of Statewide Revenues
% of Statewide Admissions
Chicago Vicinity Empress
Joliet Elgin Joliet
50,000 29,850 39,000 41,384
8.40%
7.74%
Grand Victoria Casino
20.51% 19.51% 14.16% 62.56%
14.69% 17.46% 11.10% 50.99%
Harrah’s
Hollywood Casino
Aurora
Chicago Total
160,234
St. Louis Vicinity Argosy Casino Queen St. Louis Total Other Communities Harrah’s
Alton
23,000 40,000 63,000
5.89%
8.04%
East St. Louis
10.33% 16.22%
15.55% 23.59%
Metropolis Rock Island
30,985 42,000 26,116 99,101
8.24% 4.93% 8.05%
7.45% 8.71% 9.26%
Jumers
Par-A-Dice
Peoria
Other Communities Total
21.22%
25.42%
9 | Raise Your Expectations
In the wake of former Illinois Governor Rod Blagojevich’s scandal that resulted in his departure from office, a racketeering lawsuit was filed by a group of casinos against Blagojevich and a prominent racetrack owner over the controversial law in which casinos were forced to subsidize struggling live racing operations. In the suburban Chicago area, construction will soon begin on the state’s 10th licensed casino, which is slated to open in 2011. Legislation is being considered to allow gambling within Chicago’s city limits as well as to allow free alcoholic beverages at casinos to promote increased gambling. Overall, the Chicago market is the strongest from a revenue standpoint, as its leads in AGR per square foot, patron, electronic gaming devices, and table games. Illinois casinos in the Chicago area have an AGR per patron of $121.61, which is much stronger than the $85.11 produced by their Indiana-based competition. The St. Louis metropolitan market in Illinois yields an AGR per patron of $68.14, which is slightly higher than the competing Missouri properties, which report $66.32. The properties located in the smaller communities generated the least revenue per square foot; however, they netted $82.70 in AGR per patron, $14.56 more than the eastern St. Louis metropolitan market. The smaller communities yielded the least AGR per table game and electronic gaming device, while producing the highest hold percentages.
Adjusted Gross Receipts by Region
$1.5B
$1B
$500M
$0
Chicago Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
2007
2008
2009
Adjusted Gross Receipts Analysis
$121.61
$6K
$130
$5,579.17
$82.70
$68.14
$86
$4K
$3,059.52
$3,678.46
$43
$2K
$0
$0
Chicago Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
AGR per Square Foot
AGR per Patron
Electronic Gaming Devices Analysis
8.96%
8.04%
$500
9.00%
$481.47
6.13%
6.00%
$333
$253.56
$216.05
3.00%
$166
0%
$0
Chicago Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
AGR per EGD per Day
Average EGD Hold
Table Games Analysis
20.44%
$3K
21.00%
17.14%
16.60%
$2K
14.00%
$2,968.73
$1,384.44
$1,189.13
7.00%
$1K
0%
$0
Chicago Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
AGR per Table Game per Day
Average Table Game Hold
www.rubinbrown.com | 10
Indiana Gaming Statistics
Majestic Star II
While still experiencing a downturn, the gaming industry in Indiana has not suffered as severely as other states. Indiana’s casino revenues dropped in 2009 3.4 percent from the prior year, as compared to the national 6.5 percent decline. Indiana’s gaming revenues fared better than its neighboring states
due in part to continuing capital investments in new operations, including: • June 2009 - New Hollywood casino opened, replacing the former Argosy property. • April 2009 – French Lick opened a golf course and resort designed by Pete Dye. • January 2009 – Blue Chip opened a new 22 story hotel.
Blue Chip
Ameristar
Majestic Star
Horseshoe - Hammond
Hollywood Casino
French Lick
Grand Victoria
Belterra
Horseshoe - Elizabeth
Casino Aztar
Indiana Gaming Statistics
Legalization Date
November 1993
First Casino Opening Date
December 1995
Current Number of Commercial Gaming Properties
11
2009 Commercial Gaming Admissions
26,436,995
2009 Commercial Casino Revenue
$2,378,757,261
2009 Commercial Gaming Tax Revenue
$762,730,283
Gaming Square Feet
% of Statewide Revenues
% of Statewide Admissions
Chicago Vicinity Ameristar Blue Chip Horseshoe Majestic Star Majestic Star II Chicago Total
East Chicago Michigan City
53,492 65,000 108,000 43,000 40,261 309,753
11.65% 7.89% 22.16% 4.65% 4.02% 50.37% 4.79% 3.52% 12.27% 20.58% 6.51% 4.63% 17.91% 29.05%
12.29% 9.65% 20.77% 5.27% 5.27% 53.25% 4.91% 4.23% 10.31% 19.45% 7.06% 5.68% 14.56% 27.30%
Hammond
Gary Gary
Southeastern Indiana Casino Aztar
Evansville French Lick
38,360 45,200 86,600
French Lick Horseshoe
Elizabeth
Southeastern Total
170,160
Ohio River Communities Belterra
Florence Rising Sun
40,200 40,000 150,000 230,200
Grand Victoria
Hollywood
Lawrenceburg
Ohio River Total
11 | Raise Your Expectations
Adjusted Gross Receipts by Region
While overall revenues in Indiana declined, patronage increased 4 percent from 25.4 million to 26.4 million. In 2009, the Indiana Gaming Commission also began an examination of Indiana’s industry as compared to other states. Topics include land-based casinos, non-smoking accommodations, and competitiveness with tribal casinos. Going forward, Indiana will face increased competition from Ohio’s recent legalization of commercial gaming and the addition of Illinois’ tenth casino in the Chicago suburbs. Even though the Chicago area casinos have Indiana’s highest AGR per square foot, they are still 31 percent less than the competition on the Illinois side. The AGR per patron is also lower in the Chicago vicinity as compared to the other regions. This statistic is consistent with the trend in large metropolitan communities, as these properties offer additional non-gaming attractions that increase admissions figures. The casinos in Southeastern Indiana have the highest EGD hold in the state, which could potentially boost AGR per EGD, but may account for why patronage is only 19.46% of the total state admissions, while being located in a larger market like Cincinnati. With regard to table games, an inverse relationship exists between table hold and AGR per table. This is consistent with the overall trend observed in the Midwest states examined. Additionally, the AGR per table followed the population centers as the Chicago vicinity is the largest, followed by the Cincinnati market, and then the other Ohio River Communities, respectively.
$1.3B
$867M
$433M
$0
Chicago Vicinity
Southeastern Indiana Ohio River Communities
2007
2008
2009
Adjusted Gross Receipts Analysis
$100
$4K
$95.78
$95.18
$3,867.92
$3,002.92
$2.7K
$90
$2,876.45
$85.11
$80
$1.3K
$70
$0
Southeastern Indiana
Ohio River Communities
Chicago Vicinity
AGR per Square Foot
AGR per Patron
Electronic Gaming Devices Analysis
13.17%
$290
14.00%
$285.45
$260.51
$279.04
$193
11.00%
9.22%
9.02%
8.00%
$97
5.00%
$0
Southeastern Indiana
Ohio River Communities
Chicago Vicinity
AGR per EGD per Day
Average EGD Hold
Table Games Analysis
$1,900
22.00%
$1,817.37
21.59%
$1,250
20.33%
$1,271.68
$1,168.10
19.56%
18.67%
$633
18.52%
16.10%
$0
St. Louis Vicinity Southeastern I diana
Other Communities Ohi River Communities
Chicago Vicinity ica icinity
AGR per Table Game per Day
Average Table Game Hold
www.rubinbrown.com | 12
Iowa Gaming Statistics
The statewide performance of Iowa’s casinos was relatively stable in 2009, with patron admissions down 3.3 percent and adjusted gross receipts descending only 0.2 percent. Declining revenues at certain properties showed that Iowa is certainly not immune to the current recession, but
the state as a whole has fared better than others. This is largely due to certain existing properties moving to new, more “Vegas-style” facilities which has allowed them to attract patrons from a wider market resulting in significant increases in revenues. Iowa, which has no state-imposed limits on the number of gaming licenses issued, received four new
Diamond Jo’s - Northwood
Wild Rose - Emmetsburg
Isle of Capri - Marquette
Isle of Capri - Waterloo
Diamond Jo’s - Dubuque
Argosy
Wild Rose - Clinton
Riverside Casino
Isle of Capri Bettendorf
Harrah’s
Terrible’s Lakeside
Rhythm City Catfish Bend
Ameristar
Iowa Gaming Statistics
Legalization Date
July 1989
First Casino Opening Date
September 1991
Current Number of Commercial Gaming Properties
14
2009 Commercial Gaming Admissions
16,269,750
2009 Commercial Casino Revenue
$945,119,517
2009 Commercial Gaming Tax Revenue
$202,611,979
City
Gaming Square Feet
% of Statewide Revenues
% of Statewide Admissions
Metropolitan Communities Ameristar
Council Bluffs
38,500 20,498 33,406 28,729 29,062
16.72% 6.01%
13.43% 6.60%
Argosy Harrah’s
Sioux City
Council Bluffs
9.45% 8.76% 5.94%
8.69% 7.21% 5.87%
Isle of Capri Rhythm City
Bettendorf Davenport
Metropolitan Total
150,195
46.88%
41.80%
Mississippi River Communities Catfish Bend
Burlington Dubuque Marquette
23,000 35,859 18,747 19,681 97,287 38,946 41,964 29,000 36,200 16,270 162,380
4.10% 7.46% 3.21% 4.15%
4.95% 7.83% 2.41% 4.98%
Diamond Jo’s Isle of Capri
Wild Rose
Clinton
Mississippi River Communities Total
18.92%
20.17%
Central Iowa Communities Diamond Jo’s
Northwood
8.38% 8.38% 9.11% 5.34% 2.99%
7.60% 9.28% 12.64% 5.10% 3.41% 38.03%
Isle of Capri
Waterloo Riverside Osceola
Riverside Casino Terrible’s Lakeside
Wild Rose
Emmetsburg
Central Iowa Total
34.20%
13 | Raise Your Expectations
Adjusted Gross Receipts by Region
applicants for casino licenses in November of 2009 (the selection process is expected to take at least six months). In addition, there is significant new gaming-related legislation being considered in 2010. The gaming industry in the Mississippi River Communities and Central Iowa are comparable statistically because casinos in these regions are significantly smaller (in size and number of gaming devices) than in the metropolitan communities. The larger metropolitan communities also experience a significantly higher AGR per patron. Interestingly, this trend does not hold true for the metropolitan casinos in other states. In Iowa, there appears to be a positive correlation between table hold and AGR per table, which is dissimilar to the relationship noted in the other states. On the legislative front, Iowa is currently working on bills that could: • Eliminate live greyhound racing (there are two existing facilities) • Allow major poker tournaments at casinos • Permit bars to install video gaming devices • End the existing requirement that communities vote every eight years on whether or not to retain the casinos within their jurisdiction • Legalize betting on professional sports How much of this legislation actually passes in 2010 will have a great impact on Iowa’s gaming industry.
$500M
$333M
$167M
$0
Metropolitan Communities
Mississippi River Communities
Central Iowa Communities
2007
2008
2009
Adjusted Gross Receipts Analysis
$65.00
$3K
$70
$54.00
$52.00
$2,950.00
$46
$2K
$1,991.00
$1,838.00
$23
$1K
$0
$0
Metropolitan Communities
Mississippi River Communities
Central Iowa Communities
AGR per Square Foot
AGR per Patron
Electronic Gaming Devices Analysis
9.10%
$210
9.10%
$210.00
$169.00
$160.00
8.90%
$140
8.80%
8.70%
$70
8.70%
8.50%
$0
Metropolitan Communities
Central Iowa Communities
Mississippi River Communities
AGR per EGD per Day
Average EGD Hold
Table Games Analysis
$800
23.00%
$728.00
22.00%
21.67%
$533
$533.00
$502.00
21.35%
20.33%
$266
20.40%
19.00%
$0
Metropolitan Communities
Central Iowa Communities
Mississippi River Communities
AGR per Table Game per Day
Average Table Game Hold
www.rubinbrown.com | 14
Missouri Gaming Statistics
Missouri continued its trend of increasing revenues, a feat made all the more impressive by the economic environment in which it occurred. Several events can be attributed to Missouri’s increased revenues, including:
• Smoking ban enacted by Illinois in 2007, which has caused many patrons to frequent the properties on the Missouri side • Missouri’s elimination of the $500 loss limit (per two hours of play) • Continued growth and success of Lumiére Place Casino in downtown St. Louis
Mark Twain
Terrible’s
Argosy
Harrah’s
Ameristar
Ameristar
Lumiére Place
Harrah’s
Isle of Capri
Isle of Capri Boonville
President Casino
Lady Luck
Missouri Gaming Statistics
Legalization Date
August 1993
First Casino Opening Date
May 1994
Current Number of Commercial Gaming Properties
12
2009 Commercial Gaming Admissions
25,827,559
2009 Commercial Casino Revenue
$1,730,315,761
2009 Commercial Gaming Tax Revenue
$469,057,774
City
Gaming Square Feet
% of Statewide Revenues
% of Statewide Admissions
Kansas City Vicinity Ameristar
Kansas City
140,000 62,000 63,300 21,400 286,700 130,000 120,000 75,000 18,000 343,000
13.99% 11.50% 11.30%
14.04% 10.44% 10.76%
Argosy Harrah’s
Riverside
North Kansas City
Isle of Capri
Kansas City
4.81%
6.07%
Kansas City Total
41.60%
41.31%
St. Louis Vicinity Ameristar
St. Charles
17.28% 17.03% 11.70%
16.05% 14.28% 15.21%
Harrah’s
Maryland Heights
Lumiére Place
St. Louis St. Louis
President
1.31%
2.25%
St. Louis Total
47.32%
47.79%
Other Communities Isle of Capri
Boonville
28,000 45,300 53,800 18,000
4.79% 1.95% 2.14% 2.20%
4.56% 1.65% 2.23% 2.46%
Lady Luck Mark Twain
Caruthersville
La Grange St. Joseph
Terrible’s
Other Communities Total
145,100
11.08%
10.90%
15 | Raise Your Expectations
St. Louis area revenues are expected to increase again in 2010 as the 13th licensed property, River City Casino, is unveiled in south St. Louis City in early 2010. While the new property is expected to increase overall gaming revenues for the state, the increase may be offset by the uncertain future of the President Casino. AGR totals for the western Missouri properties may be adversely affected since new competition will soon be entering the Kansas City market. In 2011, Hollywood Casino is expected to open in Wyandotte County, which will be Kansas’ second commercial casino. AGR per patron is highest in the non- metropolitan communities. This may be due in part to the fact that the metropolitan-area casinos are considered more “Vegas-style” and offer more non-gambling attractions. These entertainment venues allow properties to attract higher patron volume; however, gaming revenues per patron tend to be lower since the patron’s primary purpose varies between gaming and non-gaming activities. Missouri follows the trend experienced in most other states, in which the non- metropolitan communities have the lowest AGRs and the lowest EGD holds, but the highest table holds. While casinos in non-metropolitan areas are, on average, about half the size of those in larger cities (and have significantly less tables and EGDs), they experience about two-thirds of the patronage which boosts their average statistics.
Adjusted Gross Receipts by Region
$900M
$600M
$300M
$0
Kansas City Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinty
Other Communities
2007
2008
2009
Adjusted Gross Receipts Analysis
$69
$3K
$2,511.07
$2,386.81
$68.11
$67
$2K
$63.48
$1,321.04
$66
$1K
$66.32
$65
$0
Kansas City Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity Other Communities
AGR per Square Foot
AGR per Patron
Electronic Gaming Devices Analysis
9.20%
$240
$230.62
9.18%
8.97%
$160
$237.98
8.99%
$138.52
8.73%
$80
8.66%
8.50%
$0
Kansas City Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
AGR per EGD per Day
Average EGD Hold
Table Games Analysis
$1,200
24.00%
$1,149.67
$1,054.06
23.17%
$800
22.33%
$652.51
20.67%
$400
20.98%
20.96%
19.00%
$0
Kansas City Vicinity
St. Louis Vicinity
Other Communities
AGR per Table Game per Day
Average Table Game Hold
www.rubinbrown.com | 16
RubinBrown Hospitality & Gaming Services
RubinBrown’s Hospitality and Gaming Services Group consists of well-trained, dedicated professionals who are familiar with the specific accounting, tax and business aspects of the gaming industry. Beyond these traditional services, we also offer specialized knowledge of the industry and familiarity with the many specific challenges and issues encountered by gaming operations. We have the expertise to evaluate the overall effectiveness of a casino’s operations and analyze the performance of the various phases Assurance and Accounting Services • Audits, reviews and compilations of financial statements • Audits of pension and 401(k) plans • Adjusted Gross Receipts and Regulatory Compliance Audits Consulting Services • Policy and procedure development and documentation • Internal control and operation reviews • Contract compliance and accounts receivable reviews • Inventory controls review • Forensic accounting • Payment card industry (PCI) data security standards review • ERP and application audit • Pre and post system implementation review • Cash flow and financing analysis within the gaming industry. Specialized serviced include:
Information Technology Consulting • System procedures and controls consulting • Integration with other operating systems and general ledger packages • Retail inventory management system implementation • MAS90 and Great Plains implementation, support, and training Tax Compliance and Consulting
• Federal, state and local tax preparation • Real estate and personal property tax
• Sales and use tax compliance • Employment taxes compliance • Wealth management • Retirement and estate planning
SOURCES: American Gaming Association Colorado Department of Revenue - Division of Gaming Illinois Gaming Board Indiana Gaming Commission Iowa Racing and Gaming Commission Kansas Racing and Gaming Commission Louisiana Gaming Control Board Michigan Gaming Control Board Mississippi Gaming Commission Missouri Gaming Commission Nevada Gaming Control Board New Jersey Casino Control Commission Ohio Secretary of State Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board South Dakota Gaming Commission
Contact:
Todd Pleimann, CPA Managing Partner – Kansas City todd.pleimann@rubinbrown.com 913-499-4411
Chelle Adams, CPA Partner-In-Charge Gaming Services Group chelle.adams@rubinbrown.com 314-290-3329
17 | Raise Your Expectations
Notes
www.rubinbrown.com | 18
Saint Louis Office One North Brentwood Blvd. Saint Louis, Missouri 63105
Kansas City Office 10975 Grandview Dr., Building 27 Suite 600 Overland Park, Kansas 66210
ph: 314.290.3300 fax: 314.290.3400
ph: 913.491.4144 fax: 913.491.6821
www.rubinbrown.com
Made with FlippingBook - Online catalogs